Who We Are
The Piety Group is a local, family-owned independent insurance agency proudly serving the Western New York community. We specialize in Medicare health insurance plans, offering personalized support to help you make confident, informed decisions about your healthcare coverage.
Navigating Medicare can be overwhelming—but it doesn't have to be!
Trusted, Local, and Here for You
At The Piety Group, we’re more than just an insurance agency—we’re your neighbors, your advocates, and your trusted guides through one of the most important decisions you'll make: choosing the right Medicare health insurance plan.
As a family-owned, independent agency based in Western New York, we pride ourselves on building lasting relationships with the people we serve. For years, we’ve been helping individuals and families across our community navigate the complexities of Medicare with clarity, compassion, and confidence.
Why We’re Different
We know that Medicare isn’t one-size-fits-all. Everyone's health needs, financial situations, and personal preferences are different—and so are the plans available to them.
Being independent means we’re not tied to any single insurance provider. We have access to a broad range of Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement, and Prescription Drug Plans from well-known, reputable insurers. That allows us to focus on what truly matters: finding the right plan for you.
That's why our independent agents take the time to listen first, then offer tailored guidance with no pressure or sales gimmicks.
Let’s Talk Medicare
Whether you're turning 65 soon, already enrolled in Medicare and looking for a better fit, or helping a loved one make sense of their options, The Piety Group is here to help.
We’re happy to meet in-person, over the phone, or virtually—whatever works best for you.
We invite you to experience what makes The Piety Group different: local care, family values, and trusted Medicare expertise.
Contact us
Ready to get started or just have a question?
Contact us today and let’s talk about how we can help you feel confident in your Medicare choices.